With both teams hitting stride, set three got off to a contentious start as the teams traded blows until Navy found their stride and collected a 9-1 run to open up a 15-6 differential. The Black Knights fought to regain ground and end the match in three sets but the Mids kept the pressure high and claimed set three at 25-19.
Navy took off like a shot in the start of set four, picking up three kills in three points to open the scoring, surging to a 10-5 lead on a kill and an ace. The Black Knights drew from the crowd's energy to make a push to catch the Mids, pulling within one point at 14-13 before Navy opened the gap once more to a 19-13 difference. Army closed the gap once more with kills from their front row to pull within one point for the second time at 21-20.
Chloe Murakami then hammered home a kill off of a set from freshman setter Naomi Chinchar to bring the two teams tied, recovering from and Army service error to bring things tied again at 22-22 with another kill. A pair of Black Knight attacks that landed just wide of the court gave Navy a set point opportunity that Juliette Myrick delayed with a kill before a mishandled ball clinched the fourth set for the Mids.
The two teams battled for dominance from the first whistle of the tiebreak set, hitting ties at 1-1, 2-2, 3-3, 4-4, and 5-5 before the Back Knights put up a pair of kills back-to-back from Gimes and Myrick game Army the edge at 7-5. Army earned eight points first in the set on a kill from Myrick, making the two teams change sides where Kealakai Bandy put up a kill for the Black Knights to put Army up 9-6.
The Mids would not go quietly, however, and pieced together a 7-2 run to earn the first match point opportunity of the night at 14-12. Army would not be outdone in their own gym though, and kills from Myrick and Murakami, along with a Navy attack error, put Army up to a 15-14 lead and the second match-point opportunity of the night.
Navy's squad nabbed a block to bring things tied, but with the crowd behind them, the momentum belonged entirely to the Black Knights.
Murakami brought Army to their second match point opportunity of the night with a kill to capitalize on a long rally before freshman Victoria Filippova ended another knockdown drag-out rally with a decisive overpass kill to secure Army's first chance to sing second.